Rows of people seated at laptops in a large lecture hall during a presentation.
← Back to Blog
AI in Education

A Philosophy Department's AI Ban Shows What One Clear Rule Looks Like

Head portrait of Alex Goryachev
Alex Goryachev·November 17, 2026·5 min read

Trinity College's philosophy department voted unanimously to forbid AI "in any capacity and for any purpose," choosing one blanket rule over six that could contradict each other.

Key Takeways

  • The Department of Philosophy at Trinity College in Hartford, Connecticut, adopted a policy forbidding deliberate AI use in philosophy courses "in any capacity and for any purpose," and the Trinity Tripod reported that the faculty vote was unanimous.
  • Trinity philosophy professor Shane Ewegen said the department wanted to avoid "six different AI policies that contradict each other," and that one-rule method can serve a university whether its departments ban AI or require it.
  • A degree is a four-year bet: students choosing AI majors are wagering on AI fluency, while Trinity's philosophy faculty are wagering that unassisted thinking is the asset that lasts longest.
  • No evidence yet shows whether the Trinity College AI ban helps or harms student outcomes, so confident claims in either direction are premature.

Bring Alex to your organization: keynotes, workshops and advisory, in person or virtual. Check Alex's availability

The philosophy department at Trinity College in Hartford, Connecticut, has adopted an AI ban that reaches every philosophy course and every purpose. The policy opens with one sentence: "Deliberate use of AI in philosophy courses, in any capacity and for any purpose, is forbidden." University leaders can learn as much from how the department built this rule as from what it forbids.

Justin Weinberg reported the policy at Daily Nous on November 16, and according to the Trinity Tripod, the student newspaper, the faculty vote was unanimous. The text spells out what it covers: summarizing readings, brainstorming, research for presentations or oral exams, and writing or editing help such as drafting and compiling a bibliography. It lists no exceptions. No effective date appears in the reporting.

The department chose one rule over six

Shane Ewegen, a professor in the Trinity College philosophy department, gave the Trinity Tripod the reasoning in a single line.

"Ultimately, we wanted to avoid having six different AI policies that contradict each other."

The faculty settled on what Ewegen described as "a single blanket policy, which simply forbids the use of AI in any capacity in any philosophy course."

The phrase about six contradicting policies is the one I would put in front of every provost this year. Inconsistent rules reach students one syllabus at a time. A sophomore with a paper due at midnight needs a plain answer to a plain question: am I allowed to use this tool on this assignment? When the answer changes from one professor to the next, the student carries the risk of guessing wrong. The cost of a wrong guess is a grade, or a meeting with an academic integrity office that no 19-year-old forgets.

Coherence is turning into a policy question at every level of higher education. In England, the Office for Students has published guidance on secure, AI-free assessment. In Hartford, one department settled the question for its own courses, in its own words.

Every degree is a four-year bet

I think of a degree as a four-year bet. A student and a family commit tuition and time to the institution's judgment about what will still matter at graduation, and the future that judgment was made on keeps moving while the student is enrolled. The institution places much of that bet on the student's behalf, through the courses it builds, and the student lives with the result. Across US computer science departments, students are placing that bet on AI itself. I have written about AI majors in US computer science departments nearly doubling, and I read that growth as students wagering that the labor market will expect AI fluency from them.

Trinity College's philosophy department is placing a different bet. Its policy closes by describing philosophy as thinking, reading, writing, speaking, reasoning and living ethically, and it states that "AI undermines all of these goals." The wager is that four years of unassisted thinking builds the asset that lasts longest, whatever the job market asks for next.

Both bets can be defended. A graduate who works fluently with AI tools has a skill employers are asking for now. A graduate who can work through a hard argument alone has a skill that holds its value as the tools change. That second point connects to what I call curriculum half-life: a course built around a specific tool can age within a few semesters, while close reading and careful argument age slowly. The philosophy department has chosen to spend its four years on the slow-aging part.

Philosophy has argued about tools since Plato

This argument is as old as the discipline. In Plato's Phaedrus, written in the 4th century BC, Socrates warns that writing will weaken memory and give learners the appearance of wisdom without the substance. We know about that warning because Plato wrote it down. Serious minds have stood on both sides of the question of what a new tool does to thinking for about 2,400 years, and a philosophy department taking a firm position is working inside its own tradition.

The evidence on outcomes does not exist yet

Nobody can say whether the ban will produce stronger philosophers, and nobody can say it will fail. The policy is new, and evidence of its outcomes does not exist yet. I would be cautious with anyone who claims to know either way this early.

Ewegen named a wider aim as well. He said the goal is to get "more faculty and more students, and hopefully more administrators" to think more critically "about the role that this technology is playing in academia right now." That aim holds up wherever a reader lands on the ban itself.

The method transfers to any department

The part worth copying works for a department that bans AI and for one that requires it. Trinity's philosophy faculty wrote one rule a first-year student can read in 10 seconds, and they grounded it in what their discipline says it exists to do. A computer science department could use the same method and reach the opposite conclusion, and its students would still know where they stand. Students can plan around a strict rule or a permissive one. A rule that shifts with every syllabus is the one they cannot plan around.

These are the questions I would bring to the next meeting of deans or trustees. How many different AI rules does one student at your institution encounter in a single semester? Could each department state its rule in one sentence, with its reason in one more? Those questions run through all of my writing on AI in education, and they apply whichever way a department decides.

I hold the Innovator-in-Residence role at Tulane University, so I think about the four-year bet from inside a university, and I'm easy to find if your campus is working through its own rule.

Trinity College's philosophy department needed one sentence to tell its students where it stands. Every department on your campus can write its own, whichever bet it makes.

Should AI rules be set by each academic department or by the whole university?

Department-level AI rules can work when each one fits in a single plain sentence, with a reason drawn from that discipline's own goals, which is the approach Trinity College's philosophy department took. A campus-wide default still helps, because students cross departments every semester. One practical structure is an institutional default that each department either confirms or replaces with its own one-line rule, published where students will see it before the first assignment is due.

Will a philosophy department's AI ban hurt students looking for jobs?

The effect of a philosophy department's AI ban on graduates' job prospects is unknown, because no outcome data exists for a policy this new. The Trinity College policy as reported covers philosophy courses, so students can still build AI fluency in other courses or through internships. A student weighing the trade-off can ask one useful question of any major: which skills will this program build that the rest of my transcript will miss?

Here is what makes Alex a credible voice on this topic: Alex Goryachev is Innovator-in-Residence at Tulane University and spent 20 years at Cisco, where he shaped a $1.1B innovation portfolio, so he looks at campus AI rules from inside a university and from the employer side that a degree is meant to prepare students for.

Invite Alex to work through AI policy with your deans and trustees →

← Back to Blog
Head portrait of Alex Goryachev
Alex Goryachev

WSJ bestselling author of Fearless Innovation · Built and ran Cisco's Global Innovation Centers in 14 countries · Has advised Dell's GenAI practice and the California State University system

Work with Alex

Bring this thinking to your organization

Alex works with executive teams at global enterprises on AI strategy, governance frameworks, and organizational readiness. Available for keynotes, C-suite workshops, and advisory engagements.

Check Alex's availability

Replies within one business day.
Prefer email? [email protected]
Thank you — Alex will reply within one business day.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.